top of page
Ofer Chertkoff

Choosing the Best Toilet and Sewage System Solution for your Off-Grid Farm

When you are about to choose a suitable sewage system solution for your off grid farm It's necessary to consider factors such as local regulations, soil conditions, water availability, costs and maintenance capabilities. But not less important to take into account your level of involvement in operating the system, since most of us do not like to deal with the issue more than necessary, in addition, it is important to choose a system that will protect the water sources in your property and because we deal with organic residues, we can even harness the system for our service and produce renewable energy that will serve us in our daily lives.


Here are some sustainable important factors for the right sewage system on an off-grid farm:



Environmental protection and reducing impact

Proper sewage systems prevent the contamination of soil and water resources. This is crucial for maintaining the ecological balance of the surrounding environment, protecting local ecosystems and biodiversity.

Sustainable sewage systems often have lower environmental impacts compared to traditional systems. For example, dry-compost toilets and reducing the need for water.


Water Conservation

Sustainable sewage systems, such as dry-compost toilets or Biogas toilets contribute to water conservation. By not using it at all or by reusing water to flush the toilet, the farm can reduce its overall water demand and the installation cost of running the water system to the toilet.


Nutrient Recycling

Certain sewage systems, like composting toilets and Biogas digesters, allow for the recycling of nutrients from human waste. The resulting compost or liquid fertilizer can be used as a natural and nutrient-rich fertilizer for crops, promoting soil fertility and increasing yield production.


Energy Generation

Biogas digesters can convert through bacterial process organic waste, including human waste, into cooking Biogas for conventional stoves in addition to liquid fertilizer. This provides an additional source of renewable energy for the farm, contributing to energy self-sufficiency and reducing reliance on non-renewable energy sources.


Long - Term Cost Savings:

While there may be initial costs associated with setting up sustainable sewage systems, they often lead to long-term cost savings. Reduced water consumption, lower energy consumption, use of recycled nutrients and producing renewable energy can contribute to overall operational efficiency.


A well-designed and sustainable sewage system is essential for environmental protection, resource conservation, and overall farm resilience. Here is a list of the best toilet and sewage system solutions ranging from lower to higher costs:


Dry-compost toilet:

This is the most simple, environmentally friendly sewage system that exists. It Does not require sophisticated planning, but it  requires following a few simple principles to keep the system in a pleasant state of use. dry-Compost toilets are a cost-effective off-grid solution that breaks down human waste through the action of aerobic bacteria into compost. This system can be performed in two different ways that are based on the same principle of composting your human waste without using water .

Permanent toilet- in this method the toilet boot is permanent with a design (it can look very usual) that allow to locate inside the boot in a nice and comfortable way a container where you can do your needs and then cover it with some sawdust or dry leafs to prevent bad odor and attraction to flies. After the container is full, it's necessary to empty it to a bigger container or hole in the ground where it can compost for at least a year until using it to fertilize soil. very simple method and design but you will need to deal in some way with human waste every time the container is full.

Mobile toilets- same concept just now the toilet boot is the one that is moving, the idea is to dig a big hole in the ground and to locate the toilet boot above it in the way that you do your needs exactly and directly to the hole and then cover it with some dry leafs/sawdust. in this method you won't deal with your human waste very often but you need to have the efficient way to move your toilet boot when it's time.

It is important to locate your toilet boot far from your water source to prevent pollution and not to plant anything edible for a year at least after you cover the hole.

Pros: 

  • Low costs - just initial costs in designing your toilet boot (recycling material will save costs).

  • does not consume water.

  • Produce high quality compost from human waste.

  • Don't have a footprint at all. 

Cons:

  • Need of disposal every few days. 

  • Potential odor issues.

  • Regular digging of new holes.

  • If not treated well can impact the environment.


Vermicompost- toilet:

Vermicomposting or Vermitank is a type of composting toilet that utilizes earthworms (usually red wigglers) to decompose the organic waste in that case human feces. Basically the earthworms digest the organic matter and excrete it as quality compost, we will explain the separating process of the earthworms from the compost and the installation process in another article. So in this system the toilet can be a conventional toilet connected to water for flushing the residues, but the difference from the conventional system is the sewage, connected to a big container, his size will determine consider to the capacity requirements, with drain holes to drain the fluids without allowing the earthworms or other solids to drain, in that container we will place the earthworms and let them do the rest of the work. When flushing water to transport waste through a plumbing system to the Vermitank, the liquids will drain to the ground after they will go through natural filtration inside the container and the solids will be the delicacy for the earthworms. 

Pros: 

  • Reduction of waste volume - Vermicomposting significantly reduces the volume of waste produced. The worms break down the organic material, leaving behind compact, nutrient-dense compost that can be used as fertilizer.

  • Low Water Usage- Similar to other composting toilets, vermicomposting toilets typically require minimal water for flushing, making them a water-efficient option, especially important in off-grid sites.

  • Quality compost - The resulting vermicompost is a high-quality, nutrient-rich fertilizer. It is rich in beneficial microorganisms and can be used to enhance soil fertility in gardening or farming activities.

  • Low costs - just initial costs in installing your toilet boot, sewage pipes system and the Vermitank (recycling material will save costs).

Cons:

  • Need some basic knowledge for proper installation.

  • If not treated well can impact the environment and cause potential odor issues.

  • Regulatory compliance - depending on the location, there may be regulations governing the use of vermicomposting toilets. It's important to check local regulations and obtain any necessary

  • permits.



Biodigester toilet:

A biodigester is typically associated with a system that treats organic waste, often from toilets or kitchens, through anaerobic digestion. This process involves the breakdown of organic matter by microorganisms in the absence of oxygen, Biodigester toilets incorporate an anaerobic digestion chamber where the breakdown process takes place, producing biogas for cooking and liquid fertilizer. The installation process is very similar to the vermitank/septic just here the residues will flush to the biodigester where the breakdown process takes place. The activation process after the system is set can take from week to 3 weeks, in that time the bacteria add to the biodigester from cow manure reproduces and develops.

Pros: 

  • Biogas and fertilizer Production - One of the main advantages is the production of cooking biogas, a renewable energy source composed mainly of methane and a quality liquid fertilizer, contributing to energy self-sufficiency

  • Reduced environmental impact - help in waste management, reducing the environmental impact of untreated sewage. Biogas production also contributes to reducing the reliance on fossil fuels.

  • Low water usage - require minimal water for flushing, making them a water-efficient option.

  • Odor control - Properly designed biodigester toilets can control odors effectively, enhancing user comfort and overall sanitation.

  • The biodigester has an additional input for feeding organic waste in addition to the toilet input.

Cons:

  • Cost Considerations- While biodigester toilets may have higher initial costs, the potential benefits, such as biogas production and nutrient recycling, can contribute to long-term cost savings and sustainability.

  • Need some basic knowledge for proper installation and operation.

  • If not treated well can impact the environment and cause potential odor issues.



Conventional toilet - Septic tank:

A conventional toilet system connecting to a septic tank operating with a flush mechanism, using water to transport waste through a plumbing system to the septic tank is a common and traditional method of wastewater treatment for residential and rural areas. The septic tank is a large, mostly underground container made from plastic or concrete, where raw sewage undergoes primary treatment. It allows solids to settle at the bottom while allowing partially treated wastewater (effluent) to flow into the drain field. The drain field, also known as a leach field, disperses the partially treated effluent into the soil. It acts as a natural filter, purifying the wastewater before it reaches the groundwater. Septic tanks facilitate anaerobic digestion, where bacteria break down organic matter in the absence of oxygen. This process reduces the volume of solids and begins the treatment of wastewater.

Pros: 

  • Environmental impact - Properly designed and maintained septic systems can have minimal environmental impact. However, if not managed correctly, they may contribute to groundwater contamination or surface water pollution.

  • Longevity - With proper care, septic systems can have a long operational life. Regular inspections and timely maintenance contribute to the longevity of the system

Cons:

  • Maintenance - Regular maintenance of the septic tank is essential. This involves periodic pumping to remove accumulated solids and prevent system failure. The drain field also requires monitoring to ensure proper functioning

  • Water Usage - Traditional toilets typically use a significant amount of water for flushing, contributing to higher water consumption compared to water-saving alternatives.

  • Requires precise planning of the sewage system to prevent future mistakes that may be extremely difficult to fix.

  • Cost Consideration - The installation costs of a conventional toilet with a septic system can be relatively higher compared to the alternative systems. Besides that there are ongoing maintenance costs associated with pumping the septic tank.

  • Zero producing - this system is just a way to get rid of the organic waste and not to use the energy stored in it.



Summary


In those days when you consider which toilet system fits your needs in your off-grid farm, it's important to remember that there are systems that can produce renewable energy without any effort, it's more than just choosing a model that fits the scale and performs well. It's about choosing the system that will give you maximum energy independence even if in the short run you will spend more money.




54 views0 comments

Yorumlar


bottom of page